|
| |
|
 |
|
|
|
|
From: ADVANCE for Physical Therapists |
top |
New study at Maryville University aims to help patients with
chronic hemiplegia increase their hand function
By Brian W. Ferrie
Lending stroke patients a hand by helping them regain use of
their hands is the aim of a two-year study that will be led
by Joni Barry, DPT, PT, NCS, assistant professor of physical
therapy at Maryville University, St. Louis. Dr. Barry
received a $5,000 grant from the Missouri Physical Therapy
Association as well as $12,000 from the Greater St. Louis
Health Foundation to fund the study, which is slated to
begin this semester.
The research will divide patients who are experiencing
weakness in one side of their body into two groups. Both
groups will receive physical therapy at Maryville. One group
will wear the SaeboFlex®, an arm brace that stimulates and
supports the hand muscles, during therapy while the other
group will not. Dr. Barry's research team aims to measure
the difference in affected hand use between patients in the
two groups.
The professor has been a PT since 1989 and joined Maryville
as an adjunct faculty member in 1998. Now heading into her
fourth year as full-time faculty, Dr. Barry has also worked
with stroke patients for 15 years at St. John Mercy's
physical therapy clinic. She said the upcoming study is
important because it will help determine realistic
timetables for recovery rates in stroke patients.
Realizing Potential
"In working with stroke patients through the years, I and
the patients always felt like they had more potential than
they were able to show," she related. "Many times, patients
will try to use their hand to grab something and won't be
able to. They get discouraged and stop trying to use it."
Her research is a continuation of a pilot study involving
four stroke patients that she and Maryville physical therapy
students conducted two years ago. Those findings were
presented at the state chapter meeting in St. Louis in April
2006 as well as the national CSM conference in Boston in
February 2007.
"I had attended a course about the SaeboFlex brace in May
2005," Dr. Barry told ADVANCE. "That led me to pursue the
pilot study, which began with just five participants and
turned out to be four by the end. All four were post-stroke,
some from a bleed and some from an embolism. They were all
in the chronic stroke population, which we considered to be
more than six months post. We didn't have funding for the
pilot but we used that data to write up the grant proposal
for a larger study."
Improved Function
The pilot study demonstrated an increase in grip strength
when the statistics were reviewed, as well as some trends
toward improvement in function, continued Dr. Barry.
"We used the action research arm test as our functional
measure. When we separated the four participants, one of
them improved by nine points on that test. Ten points is
considered clinically significant, so it definitely
demonstrated a trend."
Because the pilot study was not funded, it was run mostly by
students at Maryville, added the professor.
"The braces were loaned to us by Saebo Inc., we brought in
the participants, took our pre-measures, got them set up
with the braces and taught them a home exercise program. For
six weeks, they did those exercises. We saw a few of them
periodically if they had any questions or trouble with the
fit of the brace, but there weren't really therapy
sessions."
At the end of the six-week period, the measures were
repeated and the participant who had demonstrated the most
improvement stated a desire to get the brace through his
insurance company for further use.
Study Details
The upcoming study will aim for 30 total participants, with
half randomized into a group that uses the SaeboFlex and
comes in for therapy once a week. The other half will get
therapy along with their home exercise program but will not
use the brace.
"We're going to do some reliability studies in the fall and
hope to start the actual intervention study in January," Dr.
Barry commented. "I'd like to get all the data collected in
the first year. The second year will be about analyzing the
data and writing it up. The Missouri PT Association has
given us a two-year window from when we received the grant,
which was in May, until we finish."
Participants in this study do not necessarily need to have
sustained a stroke.
"We really are just saying chronic hemiplegia. So it could
be after a head injury or a brain tumor. A lot of constraint
studies have taken participants with a certain amount of
ability to open their hand already. We're trying to target
the more involved population. We're looking for moderate to
severely involved hemiparesis so that our participants
wouldn't qualify for constraint studies that have already
shown a lot of potential. You have to be able to actively
squeeze your hand to use the SaeboFlex, but the brace itself
will help to open your hand."
The ages of the four participants in the pilot study ranged
from about 45 to 65. The upcoming study will seek
participants who are at least 18 years old. There will not
be any repeat participants because prior experience with the
SaeboFlex is a disqualification.
Recruiting Participants
"We are getting ready to really start recruiting
participants," said Dr. Barry in August. "We didn't want to
recruit too soon before the study. We're going to try and
get our name out there. Washington University in St. Louis
has a Website where stroke studies can advertise and
patients can see that we're looking for participants. We're
also going to recruit through some local hospitals and
stroke support groups."
Dr. Barry's co-investigators in the study will include Sandy
Ross, DPT, assistant professor of physical therapy; and Judy
Woehrle, DPT, assistant professor of physical therapy and PT
program director. After her experience with the pilot study,
Dr. Barry is optimistic about what the new study could
prove.
"The results of the pilot study make us hopeful we will see
improvement in function. We're also trying to measure
quality of life. In this larger study, we're using the
stroke impact scale to look at quality of life as well as
the action research arm and box and blocks tests for
functional results. In addition, we're going to look at what
happens with grip strength. There really aren't other
results out there on the SaeboFlex that we're trying to
match or support. We're just trying to get some research
started."
Student Involvement
Maryville physical therapy students will participate in the
new study in a variety of ways. A student research group
will help with the reliability study taking place this fall,
while students in the intervention study will assist when
patients come in for therapy sessions.
Therapy will take place once a week for one hour, with a
one-on-one ratio between participants and researchers. Dr.
Barry intends to always be present for the therapy sessions,
with the number of students accompanying her to depend on
the number of patients at any given session.
"They'll certainly get some experience with patients who
have hemiparesis as well as exposure to the whole research
process," the professor concluded. "I've already gone
through the Institutional Review Board (IRB) process of
getting approval, but as part of their participation
students will pretend they're writing up the IRB as well.
And their work on the reliability study will be turned into
a poster for their class to present to the rest of the
students and faculty here."
Brian W. Ferrie is managing editor at ADVANCE and can be
reached at bferrie@merion.com
|
|
From: Gender balancing raises bar for women |
top |
If you follow the news about college admissions, you know
that more women are applying to college than men. At some
campuses, only 40 percent of the applicants are male,
thereby making colleges' goal of achieving gender balance
even more difficult to accomplish.
Because of equal protection and Title IX laws, public
colleges cannot manipulate their gender balance. However,
private colleges are exempt from some admission restrictions
and, in the quest to achieve gender balance, some private
colleges have admitted lesser-qualified young men instead of
more qualified young women.
After years of fighting for educational equality, it is
disheartening to think that the college admissions' bar has
been raised even higher for young women. My guess is that at
some private colleges with balanced gender enrollment, women
are getting the short end of the admissions stick.
Steven Greenberger, associate dean of faculty at the DePaul
College of Law in Chicago, agrees. He believes, to some
degree, this type of discrimination is happening at small
colleges. He says colleges want to balance classes because
"once the ratio tips too far in favor of women, they [the
college] become unattractive to women because there aren't
any men around." Greenberger says gender balance is less of
an issue on a large campus, because with a large campus
population, gender imbalances would be less discernible.
College admission officers dispute the idea that they are
trying to balance their classes by gender, instead claiming
to assemble a class with other factors in mind.
"Many colleges are making little or no concerted effort to
achieve gender balance," Dan Rosenfield, dean of enrollment
management at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette says.
He adds: "I think it's safe to say that most colleges are
far more interested in concentrating efforts, which will
result in increasing the number of students with high
academic potential, achieving geographic and cultural
diversity, attracting students with special talents, and
opening the doors to more low-income students."
Patricia Rossman Skrha, director of undergraduate admission
at Baldwin-Wallace College in Berea, Ohio, agrees. Rossman
Skrha says most small colleges like Baldwin-Wallace admit
all qualified applicants, and she says young women might
feel college is inaccessible because of efforts to achieve
gender balance.
However, others deny that they recruit men to maintain
gender balance, but admit that they support the ideals of a
balanced class. Dr. Beth Triplett, vice president for
enrollment at Maryville University in St. Louis, tells me
that an unbalanced class "impacts the academic environment,"
and that males, if in the minority, "feel less comfortable,
and have fewer peers with whom they can identify." Triplett
also expresses concern for a society without college-bound
or college-educated men.
Judith Kleinfeld, professor of psychology and director of
the Boys Project at the University of Alaska-Fairbanks,
offers a slightly different perspective. Though the Boys
Project aims to "educate families, educators and the public
about the challenges our young boys are facing," Kleinfeld
says that "reverse discrimination will not solve the
problem. It creates unfortunate stereotypes of guys who are
in demand and don't have to follow rules. I don't think that
affirmative action for guys is the answer."
Kleinfeld suggests that if young men are indeed retreating
from college, "we should do a whole lot more than we are
doing in high schools to increase the skill level of guys."
Joanne Levy-Prewitt is an independent college admissions
adviser. E-mail:
jklprewitt@gmail.com
|
|
|
|
|
|